Gingerbread Pudding Recipe with Sticky Toffee Sauce

Best luxury Christmas pudding taste test

Our mission: to find the best luxury Christmas pudding available in the UK. Here are the results of our expert taste test, just in time for festive season

Looking for the best Christmas pudding to serve to guests this Christmas? Read on to find the results of our best ever luxury Christmas pudding taste test.

Advertisement

If you’re short on time but want to make your own homemade Christmas pudding check out our best ever quick and easy Christmas pudding recipe or, click and see the results of our Christmas supermarket awards, for the best supermarket Christmas pudding.

Christmas Pudding Recipe

How the best Christmas pudding taste test worked

Five members of the olive team conducted a blind taste test to find the most flavoursome luxury original Christmas pudding. We tasted six original Christmas puddings from luxury stores, bakeries and brands including Liberty and Hobbs House. The group choose 1st and 2nd place winners with the rest coming in as overall worthy runners up.


The results for the best luxury Christmas pudding taste test

Winner: Harvey Nichols Christmas pudding 

About the Christmas pudding: The Harvey Nichols traditional Christmas pudding is an inexpensive high quality Christmas pudding the whole family will love. It’s moist and moreish and packed with plenty of fruit, sultanas, cider and much more.

Comments: This winning Christmas pudding was rich in flavour, had a nice mix of fruit and whole nuts with a dense and sticky texture, and had the ideal amount of booze.

Price: £9.50/454g, harveynichols.com, ocado.com

Harvey Nichols Christmas Pudding 230g - £6.50

Second place: The Liberty London Felix and Isabelle Traditional Christmas Pudding

About the Christmas pudding: This luxury Christmas pudding is handmade in Devon by Georgie Porgie’s Puddings using their secret recipe, and comes wrapped in traditional Liberty London print.

Comments: The judges thought this Christmas pudding was slightly less like a traditional Christmas pudding, it was super boozy, cake-like and juicy in flavour. This Christmas pudding had strong spice flavours and was light to taste.

Price: £19.95/907g, libertylondon.com

Liberty London - Georgie Porgie Pudding - Felix and Isabelle

Other luxury Christmas puddings that we tried

Organic Christmas pudding Daylesford
About the Christmas pudding: Daylesford has been farming organically for over 35 years straight from the Daylesford estate. This homemade Christmas pudding uses a traditional family recipe and is sphere shaped wrapped in organic muslin.
Comments: This Christmas pudding was soft in texture and was packed with plenty of fruit and nuts. The pudding isn’t too boozy so it’s ideal for those who aren’t into boozy desserts.

Price: £20.00/900g, daylesford.com


Figgy’s Christmas pudding 
About the Christmas pudding: Figgy’s is a family run business down in Devon. All its Christmas puddings are homemade with port stout, Somerset cider and Californian raisins, and they’re all steamed in ceramic bowls.
Comments: This Christmas pudding was very well balanced, but not too sweet in overall flavour. It was packed with plenty of fruit, but not many nuts.

Price: £16.95 (medium)/550g, figgys.co.uk

Figgy's Christmas pudding

Hobbs House Christmas pudding

About the Christmas pudding: Using leftover sourdough breadcrumbs, their 62 year old sourdough starter and Wiper and True’s under carbonated ale, this pudding uses the finest ingredients. Served in a traditional Mason and Cash earthenware pudding basin.
Comments: This Christmas pudding was light in colour and quite tart in flavour, it had herbal and orange notes. This pudding would make a great alternative to the traditional Christmas pudding.

Price: £12.50/hobbshousebakery.co.uk

Hobbs House Christmas pudding

Advertisement

Burtree Deluxe Christmas pudding

About the Christmas pudding: Burtree is a family-run business creating lots of different puddings. This particular Christmas pudding uses a dark rum, barley wine and stout.
Comments: This Christmas pudding was sweet, boozy and sticky, an all in all good Christmas pudding.
Price: £4.99/ small (225g), burtreepuddings.co.uk

If you’re looking for other festive desserts, then check out our mince pie taste test here, too. 

Dunn's bakery mince pies

Plus we’ve found the best Irish cream to serve your friends and family over the festive season.

Homemade Irish cream

If you’re looking for Christmas desserts or cakes to serve your friends and family this Christmas, check out our best ever baking recipes and baking tips right here, you’re sure to find something for everyone.

Chocolate Cake Recipe with Burnt Butterscotch Frosting
Plus, if you want to buy some festive sloe gin to accompany your Christmas feast, then check out our sloe gin taste test to help you decide what to buy

Haymans sloe gin bottle