How we do our taste tests
All of the ice creams were scooped from the tubs in advance of the judges arriving and labelled A-F. The ice creams were then tasted blind and notes taken. We picked a winner and a runner-up. This taste test was conducted by food editor Janine Ratcliffe and deputy editor Lulu Grimes.
M&S Dessert Menu Madagascan Vanilla Ice Cream 500ml, £4.50
This one has a rich, creamy feel but it’s not too cloying and has a lightness that suggests the cream is balanced out by milk. This has the truest vanilla flavour of all the ice creams and the seeds are clearly visible. The closest to a good homemade one we tasted.
LIDL Gelatelli Premium Bourbon Vanilla Ice Cream 1 litre, £1.99
One for people who love clotted cream – this is incredibly rich and quite different in character from all the others. The colour is a buttery yellow and it has a subtle vanilla flavour. This would be great with sharp and sweet summer berries.
We also tried…
Booths Vanilla Ice Cream 900ml, £4.49
A popular choice. Not too sweet, milky and melting to an almost fluffy, foamy texture – this one would appeal to kids.
The Co-operative Truly Irresistible Vanilla Ice Cream 500ml, £3.49
Sweet and creamy, but light rather than overly rich. This has a subtle touch of vanilla – clean and fresh tasting.
Sainsburys Taste the Difference Vanilla Ice cream 500ml, £3
This has a slightly icy edge to the texture and a clean milky flavour. Not as rich as some of the others but a good one for scooping onto a hot apple pie.
Waitrose Seriously Madagascan Vanilla Ice Cream 500ml, £4
The sweet-toothed among us liked this but others found it a bit much. The vanilla flavour is also very pronounced so if you like your vanilla turned up to 11, this is for you.