Olive Magazine
Mango Froyo Recipe

Best dairy-free ice cream taste test

Published: June 1, 2018 at 3:43 pm
loading...

Our mission: to find the best dairy-free ice cream available in the UK. Here are the results of our expert taste test

Looking for the best dairy-free ice cream? Read on to find the results of our dairy-free ice cream taste test.

Advertisement

We’ve tested a range of dairy-free ice creams to find the best.


How the best dairy-free ice cream taste test worked

Four members of the olive team conducted a blind taste test to find the best shop-bought dairy-free ice cream. We tasted all of the biggest dairy-free ice cream brands widely available in the UK. The group choose an overall winner, and their other favourites. We have also listed others we tried.


Winner: Alpro soya vanilla ice cream

About the dairy-free ice cream: This dairy-free and vegan ice cream made with soya beans contains vanilla extract and vanilla seeds.

Comments: With its soft creamy texture, strong natural vanilla flavour and smooth consistency, this ice cream was an overall winner for us and we couldn’t tell it was dairy-free.

Price: £3.75/500ml, ocado.com

Alpro vanilla dairy free ice cream

Creamiest dairy-free ice cream: Blue Skies dairy-free mango and passion fruit ice cream

About the dairy-free ice cream: Made with coconut milk, mango purée and fresh passion fruit juice, this ice cream is suitable for vegans.

Comments: This tangy dairy-free ice cream had a thickly churned texture and was incredibly creamy.

Price: £4.99/450ml, waitrose.com

Blue Skies mango and passion fruit dairy-free ice cream

Here are our best ice cream recipes to try at home including:

  • Dairy-free no-churn banana ice cream
  • Chocolate and black pepper gelato
  • Brown butter ice cream
  • Instant mango fro-yo
  • Pecan praline ice cream
 

No-Churn Banana Ice Cream Recipe

Best classic dairy-free ice cream: Sainsbury’s deliciously free from choc iced dessert

About the dairy-free ice cream: This coconut oil based dairy-free ice cream also contains water, sugar and cocoa powder. It’s milk, egg and soya free.

Comments: This ice cream had a good classic chocolate flavour. While the flavour didn’t last for long it had a very smooth texture.

Price: £3.50/500ml, sainsburys.co.uk

Dairy-free Sainsbury's choc iced dessert

Best nostalgic dairy-free ice cream: Swedish Glace soy delightful raspberry dairy-free ice cream

About the dairy-free ice cream: This dairy-free ice cream is suitable for vegans, made with soya bean powder, coconut oil and raspberry puree.

Comments: While we felt this ice cream had a slightly artificial flavour, we enjoyed the sweetness and the creamy, slightly foamy texture.

Price: £2.50/750ml, ocado.com

Swedish Glace raspberry dairy-free ice cream

Best flavour dairy-free ice cream: Almond Dream salted caramel non-dairy ice cream

About the dairy-free ice cream: Made with almonds, soya protein, caramel and soya lecithin, this dairy-free ice cream is suitable for vegans.

Comments: Although this ice cream wasn’t as creamy as others we tried, it had a rich toffee flavour that we loved.

Price: £4.99/472ml, ocado.com

Almond dream dairy-free salted caramel ice cream

Other dairy-free ice cream we tried

Booja-Booja organic caramel pecan praline ice cream

About the dairy-free ice cream: Made with cashew nuts, agave syrup, pecan nuts and coconut syrup, this dairy-free ice cream is suitable for vegans.

Comments: Our testers were surprised to discover this was Booja-Booja as we love the hazelnut chocolate truffle one, however this one had a slightly odd oaty flavour with smoky notes and a strange aftertaste.

Price: £5.99/500ml, ocado.com

Booja-Booja dairy-free caramel pecan praline ice cream

Ben & Jerry’s dairy-free chunky monkey ice cream

About the dairy-free ice cream: This dairy-free ice cream is made with banana purée, almond pasta, pea protein and coconut oil.

Comments: While this ice cream had good chunks of walnuts, we felt it had a very artificial flavour and synthetic banana taste.

Price: £5.50/500ml, ocado.com

Ben and Jerry's dairy-free chunky monkey ice cream

Coconuts naturally coconut caramel organic dairy-free ice cream

About the dairy-free ice cream: Made with coconut sugar, coconut extract and water, this dairy-free ice cream is free from soya and suitable for vegans.

Comments: This ice cream had a strong coconut flavour however it was slightly sour and had an odd aftertaste.

Advertisement

Price: £5.29/500ml, ocado.com

Coconuts dairy-free coconut caramel ice cream

Comments, questions and tips

Choose the type of message you'd like to post

Choose the type of message you'd like to post
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Sponsored content